b stack radar

GitLab vs P4 Plan (2026): Pricing, Features & Verdict

GitLab is our pick, scoring 6.8/10 against 6.1/10 for P4 Plan on our Project Management criteria. Its biggest advantage: higher Integration score (8/10 vs 5/10). Both GitLab and P4 Plan have a free plan.

Last updated: November 2026

GitLab logo

GitLab

6.8/10

Winner

GitLab is a DevSecOps platform that combines source code, CI/CD, security, and agile planning with issues, boards, and epics for software teams.

P4 Plan logo

P4 Plan

6.1/10

Perforce's agile and hybrid planning tool, formerly Hansoft, lets large development teams such as game studios run Scrum, Kanban and Gantt plans in one system.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature
GitLab logo
GitLab
P4 Plan logo
P4 Plan
Scores
Overall Rating6.8/106.1/10
Cost4/105/10
Ease of Use5/105/10
Analytics7/107/10
Customization8/107/10
Scalability9/108/10
Support6/106/10
Integration8/105/10
Security9/108/10
Pricing
Free planYesYes
Cheapest paid plan$29/user/mo
Premium
Contact for pricing
Estimated cost for 10 usersContact for pricingContact for pricing
Features
File sharing
App integrations
Collaboration tools
Kanban boards
Reporting
Task lists
Task management
Time tracking
Timeline view
Workflow automation
DashboardsNot listed
DocsNot listed
Gantt chartsNot listed
Knowledge baseNot listed

GitLab vs P4 Plan cost by team size

GitLab and P4 Plan cost the same up to 5 users.

The plan that fits each team size, billed monthly, before add-ons and usage charges. Each cost opens that tool's pricing calculator for the team size.

Who GitLab and P4 Plan suit

AudienceGitLabP4 Plan
Developers10/10GitLab covers the full DevSecOps lifecycle: repositories, CI/CD, security scanning and planning.9/10It was built for agile software and game development and links to P4 version control.
Enterprise9/10Self-managed and Dedicated deployment options, Ultimate security features, and a publicly listed vendor suit large engineering organisations.8/10It is designed for large teams, scales to thousands of tasks and can be deployed on-premises.
Product Teams6/10Epics, roadmaps and iterations support planning, but OKRs need Ultimate and are not production-ready.7/10It includes dedicated product backlog, roadmapping and QA views.
Small Business5/10It fits small dev teams, but it is complex for small businesses that don't build software.4/10It is free for 5 users, but self-hosting adds overhead and paid pricing requires a quote.
Financial Services6/10The Dedicated single-tenant option is aimed at regulated enterprises.Not rated
Freelancers5/10The Free plan allows up to 5 users, but the platform is complex for solo work.Not rated
Government6/10Self-managed and Dedicated deployments suit regulated organisations that need control over infrastructure.Not rated
IT Teams7/10IT teams can self-manage it or use the single-tenant Dedicated option on their own terms.Not rated
Marketing Teams3/10Its planning tools are built around code workflows, and reviewers note a steep learning curve.Not rated
Mid-Market7/10Premium suits mid-sized software teams that want planning and CI/CD on one platform.Not rated
Remote Teams6/10It supports cloud-based collaboration on code and issues for distributed teams.Not rated
SaaS Companies8/10Software companies can run code, pipelines and planning in one application.Not rated
Sales Teams1/10The vendor notes say it suits non-engineering teams poorly.Not rated
Startups7/10The Free tier and the Premium plan help software startups get started, although the Free plan caps private groups at five users.Not rated

Which One Should You Choose?

GitLab logo
Why choose GitLab

  • Higher Integration score (8/10 vs 5/10)
  • Higher Customization score (8/10 vs 7/10)
  • Includes File sharing, which P4 Plan lacks

P4 Plan logo
Why choose P4 Plan

  • Higher Cost score (5/10 vs 4/10)

Pros & Cons

GitLab logo
GitLab

Pros

  • Planning, code, CI/CD, and security live in one tool, so issues link directly to merge requests and pipelines.
  • Time tracking with estimates and logged time is included on every tier, including Free.
  • It can be self-managed or run as single-tenant Dedicated, which suits regulated enterprises.
  • Reviewers on G2 and Capterra rate it about 4.5 out of 5 and praise its robust CI/CD and version control.

Cons

  • Users who don't write code face a lot of complexity, and reviewers complain about frequent interface changes.
  • Ultimate pricing isn't public, and Premium is listed only with annual billing.
  • OKRs require Ultimate and are still not ready for production; the global time tracking report is also experimental.
  • Users have long complained that epics exist only at the group level.

P4 Plan logo
P4 Plan

Pros

  • Scrum, Kanban and Gantt planning live in one system, so hybrid teams do not need separate tools.
  • Linking tasks to P4 changelists gives traceability for studios already on Perforce version control.
  • On-premises deployment and field-level permissions suit organisations with strict security requirements.
  • Free for up to 5 users, which lets small teams evaluate the full tool.
  • A GraphQL API, SDK, webhooks and an MCP server support custom workflows and AI connections.

Cons

  • Paid pricing is not published, and a Capterra reviewer called it expensive.
  • Reviewers report weak third-party integrations outside the Perforce ecosystem.
  • It has no built-in file management.
  • Some reviewers say it has become buggy and has lost touch with the games and VFX industries.
  • You have to host and maintain the server hardware yourself.

Not sold on either?

Frequently Asked Questions

GitLab scores higher on our Project Management criteria: 6.8/10 against 6.1/10 for P4 Plan. The largest gap is in Integration: 8/10 for GitLab and 5/10 for P4 Plan.

Yes, both GitLab and P4 Plan have a free plan.

GitLab has File sharing, which P4 Plan lacks.

Related Comparisons