b stack radar

Agency Matrix vs Outplay (2026): Pricing, Features & Verdict

Outplay is our pick, scoring 6.8/10 against 4.9/10 for Agency Matrix on our CRM criteria. Its biggest advantage: higher Support score (8/10 vs 4/10). Only Outplay has a free plan.

Last updated: November 2026

A

Agency Matrix

4.9/10

A browser-based agency management system and CRM from Zywave for independent personal lines insurance agencies. It covers client records, policies, renewals, commissions and accounting.

Outplay logo

Outplay

6.8/10

Winner

Outplay is a multichannel sales engagement platform. Outbound sales teams use it to run email, phone, SMS, and LinkedIn sequences that sync with their CRM.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature
A
Agency Matrix
Outplay logo
Outplay
Scores
Overall Rating4.9/106.8/10
Customization4/106/10
Analytics5/106/10
Integration5/107/10
Support4/108/10
Ease of Use5/108/10
Security7/106/10
Cost5/107/10
Scalability5/106/10
Pricing
Free planNoYes
Cheapest paid planContact for pricing$89/user/mo
Growth
Estimated cost for 10 usersContact for pricing$1,390/mo
Enterprise
Features
Collaboration
Contact Management
Integrations
Lead Management
Reporting & Analytics
Sales Automation
Built-in CallingNot listed
Mobile AccessNot listed

Agency Matrix vs Outplay cost by team size

Team sizeAgency MatrixOutplay
1 userContact for pricingFreeFree Forever
5 usersContact for pricing$695/moEnterprise
10 usersContact for pricing$1,390/moEnterprise
25 usersContact for pricing$3,475/moEnterprise
50 usersContact for pricing$6,950/moEnterprise

The plan that fits each team size, billed monthly, before add-ons and usage charges. Each cost opens that tool's pricing calculator for the team size.

Who Agency Matrix and Outplay suit

Outplay fits enterprise better than Agency Matrix.

AudienceAgency MatrixOutplay
Enterprise3/10It is aimed at independent personal lines agencies, not large carriers or large commercial brokers.5/10An Enterprise tier exists, but reviewers say it lacks some advanced features that bigger competitors have.
Small Business6/10Reviewers say it covers most of the tasks a smaller agency needs, but it only fits insurance businesses.7/10It is affordable and reviewers find it easy to use, though a separate CRM is still needed.
AgenciesNot rated5/10It can run outreach for clients, but some reviewers note costs rise for larger teams.
Customer Support TeamsNot rated1/10It has no ticketing.
Financial Services8/10It was built specifically for independent insurance agencies that handle policies, renewals and commissions.Not rated
FreelancersNot rated4/10There is a free plan and a single-user Starter plan, but it relies on an external CRM.
Mid-MarketNot rated7/10The Growth and Enterprise tiers offer unlimited seats and CRM sync for larger teams.
SaaS CompaniesNot rated6/10It targets outbound SDR teams and startups using CRMs such as Salesforce or HubSpot.
Sales TeamsNot rated9/10It is built for outbound sales development teams that run multichannel sequences.
StartupsNot rated8/10A free plan and a $39 Starter tier suit small early-stage teams.

Which One Should You Choose?

A
Why choose Agency Matrix

  • Higher Security score (7/10 vs 6/10)

Outplay logo
Why choose Outplay

  • Has a free plan (Agency Matrix does not)
  • Higher Support score (8/10 vs 4/10)
  • Higher Ease of Use score (8/10 vs 5/10)
  • Better fit for enterprise (5/10 vs 3/10)

Pros & Cons

A
Agency Matrix

Pros

  • Accounting, commission reconciliation and general ledger are built in, so a separate bookkeeping tool may not be needed.
  • It connects directly with TurboRater comparative rating and Zywave agency websites, so quotes and leads flow into client records.
  • It has tools specific to personal lines agencies, such as x-date tracking and sweep processing, which generic CRMs lack.
  • Zywave says it has SOC 2 Type II certified security and role-based permissions.

Cons

  • Reviewers often report outages, and settings that reset after upgrades.
  • Some users describe data corruption and errors when converting from another system.
  • Pricing is not published, so you need a sales quote.
  • Review ratings are mixed, at about 3.7 out of 5 on Software Advice, and the customer support score is lower.

Outplay logo
Outplay

Pros

  • Sequences can mix email, phone, SMS, WhatsApp, video, chat, and LinkedIn steps in one flow.
  • Published per-user prices are well below those of enterprise rivals such as Outreach, and there is a free plan.
  • Reviewers on G2 and Capterra often praise its responsive customer support. G2 shows an average of 4.5 from 269 reviews.
  • A 7-day Growth trial needs no credit card, and the account drops to the free plan afterwards without losing data.
  • Reviewers say the interface is intuitive, especially for reps who have used other sales tools.

Cons

  • It is not a full CRM. It has no native deal pipeline or ticketing and relies on an external CRM.
  • Some users report occasional glitches and lag in displaying responses.
  • Some users find reporting and native prospecting data limited.
  • The power dialer and team permissions are only on the $139 Enterprise tier.
  • Add-on prices and monthly billing rates are not published.

Not sold on either?

Frequently Asked Questions

Outplay scores higher on our CRM criteria: 6.8/10 against 4.9/10 for Agency Matrix. The largest gap is in Support: 4/10 for Agency Matrix and 8/10 for Outplay.

Outplay has a free plan; Agency Matrix does not list one.

Outplay is the better fit for enterprise: we rate it 5/10 for them, against 3/10 for Agency Matrix.

Related Comparisons