b stack radar

P4 Plan vs SmartSuite (2026): Pricing, Features & Verdict

SmartSuite is our pick, scoring 7.3/10 against 6.1/10 for P4 Plan on our Project Management criteria. Its biggest advantage: higher Ease of Use score (7/10 vs 5/10). Only P4 Plan has a free plan.

Last updated: November 2026

P4 Plan logo

P4 Plan

6.1/10

Perforce's agile and hybrid planning tool, formerly Hansoft, lets large development teams such as game studios run Scrum, Kanban and Gantt plans in one system.

SmartSuite logo

SmartSuite

7.3/10

Winner

SmartSuite is a no-code work management platform that teams use to build project, process and operations solutions with views, automations and AI agents.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature
P4 Plan logo
P4 Plan
SmartSuite logo
SmartSuite
Scores
Overall Rating6.1/107.3/10
Cost5/106/10
Ease of Use5/107/10
Analytics7/107/10
Customization7/109/10
Scalability8/107/10
Support6/107/10
Integration5/107/10
Security8/109/10
Pricing
Free planYesNo
Cheapest paid planContact for pricing$20/user/mo
Team
Estimated cost for 10 usersContact for pricing$200/mo
Team
Features
File sharing
App integrations
Collaboration tools
Dashboards
Gantt charts
Kanban boards
Reporting
Task lists
Task management
Time tracking
Timeline view
Workflow automation
Client collaborationNot listed
DatabasesNot listed
DocsNot listed
SchedulingNot listed
Spreadsheet interfaceNot listed
Team messagingNot listed
WhiteboardsNot listed

P4 Plan vs SmartSuite cost by team size

P4 Plan costs less at 5 users.

Team sizeP4 PlanSmartSuite
1 userFreeFreeContact for pricing
5 usersFreeFree$100/moTeam
10 usersContact for pricing$200/moTeam
25 usersContact for pricing$500/moTeam
50 usersContact for pricing$1,000/moTeam

The plan that fits each team size, billed monthly, before add-ons and usage charges. Each cost opens that tool's pricing calculator for the team size.

Who P4 Plan and SmartSuite suit

SmartSuite fits small business better than P4 Plan.

AudienceP4 PlanSmartSuite
Small Business4/10It is free for 5 users, but self-hosting adds overhead and paid pricing requires a quote.6/10The Team plan is affordable, but its three-seat minimum and 5,000-record cap constrain small teams.
Enterprise8/10It is designed for large teams, scales to thousands of tasks and can be deployed on-premises.7/10It offers SAML SSO, SCIM, ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II and HIPAA coverage, and banks and universities are named customers.
Developers9/10It was built for agile software and game development and links to P4 version control.Not rated
EducationNot rated6/10Universities use it for governance, risk and compliance tracking.
Financial ServicesNot rated7/10Banks use it for governance, risk and compliance tracking.
FreelancersNot rated3/10There is no free plan, and paid plans require at least three seats.
HealthcareNot rated7/10Healthcare organizations use it, and it has HIPAA audits.
Marketing TeamsNot rated7/10Marketing templates come with Kanban, calendar and Gantt views.
Mid-MarketNot rated8/10The Professional and Enterprise limits, granular permissions and compliance certifications suit growing organizations.
Operations TeamsNot rated8/10No-code builder for project, process and operations solutions.
Product Teams7/10It includes dedicated product backlog, roadmapping and QA views.Not rated
StartupsNot rated4/10There is no free plan and seat minimums apply.

Which One Should You Choose?

P4 Plan logo
Why choose P4 Plan

  • Has a free plan (SmartSuite does not)
  • Higher Scalability score (8/10 vs 7/10)

SmartSuite logo
Why choose SmartSuite

  • Higher Ease of Use score (7/10 vs 5/10)
  • Higher Customization score (9/10 vs 7/10)
  • Better fit for small business (6/10 vs 4/10)
  • Includes File sharing, which P4 Plan lacks

Pros & Cons

P4 Plan logo
P4 Plan

Pros

  • Scrum, Kanban and Gantt planning live in one system, so hybrid teams do not need separate tools.
  • Linking tasks to P4 changelists gives traceability for studios already on Perforce version control.
  • On-premises deployment and field-level permissions suit organisations with strict security requirements.
  • Free for up to 5 users, which lets small teams evaluate the full tool.
  • A GraphQL API, SDK, webhooks and an MCP server support custom workflows and AI connections.

Cons

  • Paid pricing is not published, and a Capterra reviewer called it expensive.
  • Reviewers report weak third-party integrations outside the Perforce ecosystem.
  • It has no built-in file management.
  • Some reviewers say it has become buggy and has lost touch with the games and VFX industries.
  • You have to host and maintain the server hardware yourself.

SmartSuite logo
SmartSuite

Pros

  • The same records can be shown as grid, Kanban, Gantt, timeline, calendar, map and dashboard views without duplicating data.
  • Its compliance coverage is unusually strong for the category, with ISO 27001, SOC 2 Type II, HIPAA and GDPR audits plus a choice of US or EU data residency.
  • Read-only users, commenters and form submitters are free, which lowers the cost of involving stakeholders.
  • It ships more than 200 templates and an AI solution builder to speed up setup.
  • Reviewers describe the support team as responsive.

Cons

  • Team, Professional and Enterprise carry 3-, 5- and 25-seat minimums, and there is no free plan.
  • The Team plan allows only 5,000 records per solution, and automation runs plus API calls are hard-capped each month.
  • SAML SSO and SCIM are available only on Enterprise and Signature plans.
  • There is no team chat or whiteboard, and external access is limited to read-only shared views.
  • Reviewers say complex workflows and large data imports take real setup effort, and there are no native desktop apps.

Not sold on either?

Frequently Asked Questions

SmartSuite scores higher on our Project Management criteria: 7.3/10 against 6.1/10 for P4 Plan. The largest gap is in Customization: 7/10 for P4 Plan and 9/10 for SmartSuite.

P4 Plan has a free plan; SmartSuite does not list one.

SmartSuite is the better fit for small business: we rate it 6/10 for them, against 4/10 for P4 Plan.

SmartSuite has File sharing, which P4 Plan lacks.

Related Comparisons