b stack radar

Retention.com vs Tolstoy (2026): Pricing, Features & Verdict

Tolstoy is our pick, scoring 6.8/10 against 5.6/10 for Retention.com on our Marketing criteria. Its biggest advantage: higher Customization score (7/10 vs 4/10). For 10 users, Tolstoy costs about $20/mo, against $500/mo for Retention.com; neither Retention.com nor Tolstoy lists a free plan.

Last updated: November 2026

Retention.com logo

Retention.com

5.6/10

An identity resolution platform that matches anonymous US website visitors to contact data, then sends them into email tools like Klaviyo to grow lists and win back abandoned carts.

Tolstoy logo

Tolstoy

6.8/10

Winner

AI ecommerce platform for Shopify and DTC brands offering shoppable video widgets, AI content and ad studios, virtual try-on and on-site AI shopping assistants.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature
Retention.com logo
Retention.com
Tolstoy logo
Tolstoy
Scores
Overall Rating5.6/106.8/10
Scalability7/107/10
Ease of Use7/107/10
Customization4/107/10
Security7/105/10
Support5/107/10
Cost3/106/10
Integration8/108/10
Analytics4/107/10
Pricing
Free planNoNo
Cheapest paid plan$500/mo
Startup
$20/mo
Plus
Estimated cost for 10 users$500/mo
Startup
$20/mo
Plus
Features
E-commerce Features

Retention.com vs Tolstoy cost by team size

Tolstoy costs less at every team size we checked.

Team sizeRetention.comTolstoy
1 user$500/moStartup$20/moPlus
5 users$500/moStartup$20/moPlus
10 users$500/moStartup$20/moPlus
25 users$500/moStartup$20/moPlus
50 users$500/moStartup$20/moPlus

The plan that fits each team size, billed monthly, before add-ons and usage charges. Each cost opens that tool's pricing calculator for the team size.

Who Retention.com and Tolstoy suit

Tolstoy fits small business better than Retention.com.

AudienceRetention.comTolstoy
Small Business3/10A starting price of around 500 USD a month and annual terms are steep for small stores.6/10The $20 Plus plan is affordable, but viewer and credit metering can push costs up as traffic grows.
E-commerce9/10Retention FLEX is built for DTC stores that feed identified visitors into Klaviyo abandonment flows.9/10It is built for Shopify and DTC stores, with shoppable video, add-to-cart from video and attributed revenue tracking.
Marketing Teams7/10Lifecycle marketers use it to grow email lists and remarketing audiences.7/10Media Studio and Ads Studio produce product creative and Meta campaigns for ecommerce marketers.
Agencies6/10Klaviyo agencies report using it for client list growth.Not rated
EnterpriseNot rated6/10An Enterprise tier offers custom contracts, permission controls and custom integrations, and large retail brands are listed as customers.

Which One Should You Choose?

Retention.com logo
Why choose Retention.com

  • Higher Security score (7/10 vs 5/10)

Tolstoy logo
Why choose Tolstoy

  • Lower estimated cost for 10 users: $20/mo vs $500/mo
  • Higher Customization score (7/10 vs 4/10)
  • Higher Cost score (6/10 vs 3/10)
  • Better fit for small business (6/10 vs 3/10)

Pros & Cons

Retention.com logo
Retention.com

Pros

  • One tag captures emails from US visitors who never submitted a form and passes them into Klaviyo flows
  • Integrates with many ESPs, CDPs and warehouses, including Klaviyo, Iterable, Segment and Snowflake
  • SOC 2 Type II certified, with public CCPA opt-out tools
  • G2 reviewers often mention quick setup, and it holds a 4.5 out of 5 rating across about 122 reviews

Cons

  • Prices are not published, and reported plans start around 500 USD a month
  • Independent reviewers report match rates of about 16 to 25 percent, below the vendor's claims
  • Contacts never opted in, which raises consent and spam-complaint risks
  • Identifies US visitors only
  • Some reviewers report difficult cancellations and annual contracts

Tolstoy logo
Tolstoy

Pros

  • Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 288 Shopify App Store reviews, and 93% of them are five stars.
  • Imports existing Instagram, TikTok and YouTube videos and makes them shoppable with add-to-cart inside the video.
  • Bundles shoppable video with AI product imagery, Meta ad creative, virtual try-on and an on-site AI shopper on every plan.
  • A broad integration list covers Shopify, Shop App, TikTok Shop, Klaviyo, Gorgias, Yotpo, Triple Whale and GA4.
  • The entry plan starts at $20 per month, or $16 per month billed yearly.

Cons

  • Monthly viewer metering means a high-traffic month brings overage charges of $5 to $10 per 1,000 viewers.
  • Credits are shared across the workspace, and extra seats cost $20 each without adding allowances.
  • Some reviewers dislike that widget customization now runs through AI prompting.
  • No security certifications are stated on the main site, and advanced permission controls are limited to Enterprise.
  • Its scope is video-first: a competitor's review notes only partial photo UGC support and no review aggregation.

Not sold on either?

Frequently Asked Questions

Tolstoy scores higher on our Marketing criteria: 6.8/10 against 5.6/10 for Retention.com. The largest gap is in Analytics: 4/10 for Retention.com and 7/10 for Tolstoy.

Tolstoy costs less for 10 users: about $20/mo on its Plus plan, against about $500/mo on its Startup plan for Retention.com, billed monthly.

No, neither Retention.com nor Tolstoy lists a free plan.

Tolstoy is the better fit for small business: we rate it 6/10 for them, against 3/10 for Retention.com.

Related Comparisons