b stack radar

Judge.me vs Tolstoy (2026): Pricing, Features & Verdict

Judge.me is our pick, scoring 7.1/10 against 6.8/10 for Tolstoy on our Marketing criteria. Its biggest advantage: higher Cost score (10/10 vs 6/10). For 10 users, Judge.me is free, against $20/mo for Tolstoy; only Judge.me has a free plan.

Last updated: November 2026

Judge.me logo

Judge.me

7.1/10

Winner

Judge.me is a Shopify app that collects and displays product reviews, star ratings, photo and video reviews, and testimonials for online stores.

Tolstoy logo

Tolstoy

6.8/10

AI ecommerce platform for Shopify and DTC brands offering shoppable video widgets, AI content and ad studios, virtual try-on and on-site AI shopping assistants.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Feature
Judge.me logo
Judge.me
Tolstoy logo
Tolstoy
Scores
Overall Rating7.1/106.8/10
Scalability6/107/10
Ease of Use8/107/10
Customization6/107/10
Security5/105/10
Support7/107/10
Cost10/106/10
Integration7/108/10
Analytics5/107/10
Pricing
Free planYesNo
Cheapest paid plan$15/mo
Awesome
$20/mo
Plus
Estimated cost for 10 usersFree
Free
$20/mo
Plus
Features
E-commerce Features

Judge.me vs Tolstoy cost by team size

Judge.me costs less at every team size we checked.

Team sizeJudge.meTolstoy
1 userFreeFree$20/moPlus
5 usersFreeFree$20/moPlus
10 usersFreeFree$20/moPlus
25 usersFreeFree$20/moPlus
50 usersFreeFree$20/moPlus

The plan that fits each team size, billed monthly, before add-ons and usage charges. Each cost opens that tool's pricing calculator for the team size.

Who Judge.me and Tolstoy suit

Judge.me fits small business better; Tolstoy fits enterprise better.

AudienceJudge.meTolstoy
Enterprise3/10It runs only on Shopify, and comparisons point enterprise brands toward Yotpo.6/10An Enterprise tier offers custom contracts, permission controls and custom integrations, and large retail brands are listed as customers.
Small Business9/10The generous free plan and flat 15 dollar paid plan suit small Shopify stores.6/10The $20 Plus plan is affordable, but viewer and credit metering can push costs up as traffic grows.
E-commerce10/10It is a Shopify review app built for online stores.9/10It is built for Shopify and DTC stores, with shoppable video, add-to-cart from video and attributed revenue tracking.
Marketing Teams6/10Ecommerce marketers can use it for social proof and Klaviyo integration, but it does not run campaigns.7/10Media Studio and Ads Studio produce product creative and Meta campaigns for ecommerce marketers.
Mid-Market6/10Growing brands can use it, though some move to Yotpo or Okendo as they outgrow it.Not rated
Social Media Teams3/10The paid plan syncs reviews to Meta and TikTok Shop.Not rated
Startups9/10Reviewers recommend it for bootstrapped stores that don't yet have a review app.Not rated

Which One Should You Choose?

Judge.me logo
Why choose Judge.me

  • Has a free plan (Tolstoy does not)
  • Lower estimated cost for 10 users: Free vs $20/mo
  • Higher Cost score (10/10 vs 6/10)
  • Higher Ease of Use score (8/10 vs 7/10)
  • Better fit for small business (9/10 vs 6/10)

Tolstoy logo
Why choose Tolstoy

  • Higher Analytics score (7/10 vs 5/10)
  • Higher Scalability score (7/10 vs 6/10)
  • Better fit for enterprise (6/10 vs 3/10)

Pros & Cons

Judge.me logo
Judge.me

Pros

  • The free plan includes unlimited reviews, photo and video reviews, and rich snippets, which reviewers call the most generous free tier in the category.
  • The paid plan is a flat 15 dollars a month instead of being priced by order volume.
  • It has about 49,700 Shopify App Store reviews averaging 5.0, and it is listed as Built for Shopify.
  • It can import reviews from Loox, Yotpo and Stamped, which makes switching easier.
  • It integrates with Klaviyo, Gorgias, Shopify Flow and Mailchimp.

Cons

  • It works only on Shopify, and support for WordPress, BigCommerce and Duda has been dropped.
  • Reviewers describe its widget design as functional rather than polished compared with Loox.
  • Some merchants report that reviews sync to the Shop app only partially.
  • Some merchants report theme conflicts after installation and disputes with support over who caused them.

Tolstoy logo
Tolstoy

Pros

  • Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 288 Shopify App Store reviews, and 93% of them are five stars.
  • Imports existing Instagram, TikTok and YouTube videos and makes them shoppable with add-to-cart inside the video.
  • Bundles shoppable video with AI product imagery, Meta ad creative, virtual try-on and an on-site AI shopper on every plan.
  • A broad integration list covers Shopify, Shop App, TikTok Shop, Klaviyo, Gorgias, Yotpo, Triple Whale and GA4.
  • The entry plan starts at $20 per month, or $16 per month billed yearly.

Cons

  • Monthly viewer metering means a high-traffic month brings overage charges of $5 to $10 per 1,000 viewers.
  • Credits are shared across the workspace, and extra seats cost $20 each without adding allowances.
  • Some reviewers dislike that widget customization now runs through AI prompting.
  • No security certifications are stated on the main site, and advanced permission controls are limited to Enterprise.
  • Its scope is video-first: a competitor's review notes only partial photo UGC support and no review aggregation.

Not sold on either?

Frequently Asked Questions

Judge.me scores higher on our Marketing criteria: 7.1/10 against 6.8/10 for Tolstoy. The largest gap is in Cost: 10/10 for Judge.me and 6/10 for Tolstoy.

Judge.me costs less for 10 users: free on its Free plan, against about $20/mo on its Plus plan for Tolstoy, billed monthly.

Judge.me has a free plan; Tolstoy does not list one.

Tolstoy is the better fit for enterprise: we rate it 6/10 for them, against 3/10 for Judge.me.

Related Comparisons